How to evaluate an MLB picks service
Seven checks you can run on any MLB picks or prediction service before paying for it, and how this site answers each one.
1. Is every past pick published, with its result?
A win rate by itself cannot be checked. A game-by-game archive can. Look for a list of every date, every pick and the final score, including the losing days.
Here: the picks archive and parlay archive are free, and every pick is graded automatically against the official final score.
2. Can you tell when each pick was locked?
A pick posted after first pitch proves nothing. A service should lock each pick before the game and should not edit it afterwards.
Here: a pick is published once starting pitchers are confirmed and is locked about fifteen minutes before first pitch. A locked pick is not changed.
3. Are different markets reported separately?
Game winners, totals, home run props and parlays behave very differently. Blending them into one number hides weak markets behind strong ones.
Here: main picks, totals, dark horse home runs and the Daily Parlay each have their own results. Within totals, Plays and Leans are also kept apart.
4. How big is the sample?
Twenty games tells you almost nothing. Several hundred starts to. Ask how many picks the quoted rate is based on and over what period.
Here: the 2026 regular season main pick record is 1303-906 (59.0%) across 2209 graded games, with the postseason listed separately.
5. Does it confuse win rate with profit?
Win rate is not return. A service that leans on heavy favourites can win often and still lose money at the prices available. Be wary of profit claims that do not state the prices used.
Here: the track record reports wins and losses only. Return figures are kept apart on a separate results page.
6. Is the price and cancellation clear?
You should be able to see the price, what each plan includes and how to cancel before you enter payment details.
Here: every pass and what it unlocks is listed on the home page, with day passes for trying it once. New pass sales pause during the offseason. The refund policy is public.
7. Does it take your bets?
An analysis service and a sportsbook are different things. A service that also profits from your wagers has a different incentive from one that only sells information.
Here: WP Baseball Predictor is an analytics service. It does not accept wagers and is for entertainment purposes only.
The 2026 season is complete
New baseball passes are unavailable during the offseason. Existing paid access remains valid through its expiry. Future Apple monthly renewals have been stopped. Every past pick and outcome stays free in the archive, and picks return on Opening Day.
Browse the free archive Track record Get the iPhone appRelated: How to read MLB matchup analysis · FAQ